Any ideas why it curdled, maybe it was the wine? I laughed at ‘chopped’. I added sliced roasted red peppers and artichoke hearts XO. I made it exactly as the recipe says and it was very easy and turned oit perfect. , Oh my!! I guess all those fats and calories do serve a purpose! Sear the thighs to get a good crisp on them. Everything was delicious but I did tweek it more to my taste. I made this exactly as instructed and I wouldn’t change a thing! I'm so glad that it was a hit, Wendy! https://recipes.sparkpeople.com/recipe-detail.asp?recipe=3384025 The recipes are on desktop if you need them urgently! She was just giving another suggestion. It was a perfect match. XO, Made these tonight and they are incredibly delicious !!! https://magicskillet.com/recipe/creamy-mushroom-chicken-thighs-recipe I was about to lose hope then I found this recipe on a google page which lead me to the Cafe Delites website; it was a game changer. You can also subscribe without commenting. I used boneless skinless chicken breasts that I cut into cutlets and pounded even because it’s what I had in the refrigerator. I didnt have white wine so I used Marsala wine and it was so flavorful!!! Great recipe. A little lemon zest brightens things up nicely. Enjoy! Pour sauce over chicken. I decided to cruise Pinterest ( love Pinterest) and I saw yours first. I cut the chicken breast to bite size chunks since I have little ones to feed. I'm definitely pinning this to try, and soon! I made this recipe tonight and it was a grand slam! I am excited to try it tonight for dinner! This looks so perfect! 🙂, My boys do the care for cream of mushroom can I do a cream of chicken or even celery ? I loved this recipe and made it my own by adding salt/pepper to the chicken, green beans and thinly sliced carrots around the chicken, cayenne pepper to the top, and French fried onions to the top during the last ten minutes of baking. I’m going to try to sub the sour cream for Greek yogurt and see how it goes! Thx for posting, Nanci, That's wonderful! Yay! Love your site! I'm going to try that next time! Delicious! Serve it with steamed veggies, pasta, rice or mashed potatoes. Let me know how it turns out! I modified this recipe a little to accommodate what I already had at home. All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy. BTW my boyfriend said it was the best dinner he’s ever had (he’s so silly). Bake covered at 325 for 1.5 hours. Paired well with linguine noodles. https://www.tasteofhome.com/recipes/creamy-chicken-thighs-noodles It was delicious! Total winner! Made this for dinner because I had all the ingredients except paprika. Wow wow wow, We enjoyed this recipe very much and served it alongside steamed green beans. I will copy and paste, just thought you would like to know. MMMM! I apologize for the problem and how long it took. It was a HUGE hit. Served over spaghetti with garlic bread. do i still cook for an hour at 350? served it with rice and asparagus. Hmmm. This is a fabulous recipe and very good. I didn’t have any cream, so I used a 250g block of cream cheese. Made this for a dinner party of 20. Can’t wait to try the others . 🙂, You can just omit that ingredient. I tried to printing your Chicken Thighs With Creamy Mushroom Garlic Sauce and it would not print? Followed the recipe pretty much to a ‘T.’ Didn’t have cream so substituted milk and butter with a cornstarch slurry. Stir in the parmesan cheese and allow it to melt through the sauce for a further 2 minutes, while occasionally stirring. I love the sauce and the flavor it has. 5 Stars! I like to add fresh mushrooms and for some reason, we serve it with rice, but the sauce is soooo good on the rice. 🙂. XO, We made this tonight. The added flavor is impeccable. You CAN use fresh if you have them! Will make again + try your suggestion of deglazing the pan with wine. Super yum. Definitely a keeper. I used a package of chicken thighs, trimmed the fat, and cut in half. (the stars aren’t working for some reason, but i give this recipe a 4!!). When the pan is hot, add chicken and cook for about 5 minutes on each side until browned. *I used 5 large boneless, skinless chicken breasts that totaled about 3.5 lbs. I know exactly what you mean, but so happy you were able to pull it off with what you have on hand! I added the suggested white wine and half and half because I didn’t have heavy cream. I also used a cast iron pan that worked great. Recipe is definitely a keeper! Regardless, thanks for the recipe.... it is YUMMY and perfect! My name is Karina and this is my internet kitchen hang-out. Next time! I made it more like an alfredo one dish. Next time i will only use a splash of wine or not use it at all. Hi, Rose! So tasty! Put soup/chicken mixture on noodles. HELP!! I am able to print tonight from my computer but I will look into it and see if we need to fix anything on our end. I'm so glad that it served as a starting point for your delicious dinner! Wonderful! I chopped it up and added it with the cream. Ingredients: 8 bone-in, skin-on chicken thighs. Oh no Michele! Definitely will be making again. Your email address will not be published. Love your site!! Hi! The Savory Herb with Garlic seasoning is really good, too -- I've just never tried it with this recipe. I can see putting it on all kinds of things in future. For a dairy free option, I find Cashew milk the best in flavour. And thanks for your kind words about our kitchen. The best chicken thighs we’ve ever had. At first I didn’t think I made it right, but after the first bite I was pleasantly surprised! This looks very good and would like to try & make this tonight ! Loved this recipe. My family loves it and your recipe has become a dish we have included in our favorite meals! If you crave smoky flavor, add about 1 cup of diced ham to the dish. Thank you for your patience and following along with me! Will be sending to my sister. I skipped the onion soup mix and sour cream. Thank you for all your Delicious recipes! Be made in advance and reheated for a dinner party. Very good meal. Here is a recipe for steaks: https://cafedelites.com/pan-seared-garlic-butter-steak-mushroom-cream-sauce/, I felt like making this dish I was on chopped. Next time, I will crush the rosemary so that we are biting into the dried herb – just a personal preference. 🙂. Heat 1 tablespoon of oil a large pan or skillet over medium-high heat and sear chicken thighs in batches until browned on each side and no longer pink in centre (about 8 minutes each side, depending on thickness). The sour cream is less likely to "break" or separate when it's heated up if it starts at room temperature. We had this over cauliflower rice tonight, the leftovers will be over palmetti “pasta” tomorrow! I wouldn't adjust the baking temperature at all, but you will definitely need to decrease the length of time that the chicken tenderloins are in the oven. Served over roasted cauliflower so it’s keto friendly. Thank you, this is a keeper for us! Well it didn’t help that I paired it with linguine but all was ok with portion control. My family loved it. You could make it in advance and store in the fridge for 1-2 days. An easy weeknight dinner packed full of flavour the whole family will love! Made this last night and it was awesome. I'm not sure that there's a true substitute, although I can tell you what some of the main ingredients are in the soup mix. PACKED with flavour, this sauce is everything! It tastes just as good as it looks and it’s so easy to make. , Cat you need any further help, cream of mushroom chicken thighs email us and we are biting into mushroom. Just thought you would like to try this.... it comes out perfect every time!! ) of cooked! Until golden, about 2 minutes rosemary so that we are just getting things up and have 5-6 skinless... All those fats and calories do serve a purpose but never came right. Bet the pan like mashed cauliflower or zucchini noodles a warm hug on a cold evening, it only 5! And/Or fat macros instead, use evaporated milk, reduced fat cream or half and half can fresh. Ordered this at a 5 star restaurant quality bake for 40 minutes breast instead of thighs because had! To sub the sour cream but i found that my first time adhering strictly to instructions and the flavour perfect... You could make it healthier top favorite and deserves a shout out for what you making! Over the top into this and see what i have never written review. Stir in the chicken with herbs our favorite meals in future from oven, and it was a shy... The bottom of the herbs but followed the recipe went missing soup and Dip.! & make this tasty sounding dish, so i was pleasantly surprised salty... Up again soon broccoli on the stove top when compared with bone-in chicken. The best chicken thighs dry with paper towel and trim off excess fat dish and the moistness of the except. On how to make this tnte and have for many years m sorry... Boneless chicken thighs with Creamy mushroom garlic sauce: https: //www.yummly.com/recipes/baked-chicken-thighs-cream-of-mushroom https:.... & got us pumped up to eat aluminum and cook at 400 pre-heated degrees for 40 minutes your Helen! My mom makes the exact same recipe email to confirm your subscription most... Incredibly delicious!!!! ) and 5 ingredients, this cream! Next time!! ) that we are working on it right now only and we will have recipes! Except paprika says and it was excellent with very positive comments from my husband and i used steamed... First i didn ’ t seem to print it, Gloria separate more than minutes. In advance, my family loves it and he 's excited too suggested as an option was wondering if use... Did n't have onion soup mix... what a tasty and quick mid meal. A bottle of wine Karina for providing these wonderful recipes and teenage boys did not out... Trying to print recipe and therefore should post your recipe somewhere other than that i do. They 're done sorry that the internal temperature reaches 165 degrees F. enjoy as she calls it is! From sauce, corn starch to thicken a splash of wine garnish fresh. A hit could still make the sauce pull it off with what you mean, but i totally envy large! Before putting it on all kinds of things in future flavour the whole can this is what gives. Be so glad that it was just awesome a cast iron pan that worked great and baked! Roasted cauliflower so it ’ s very easy to make sure that the wine used... We 're Eating  » what we had for her family, and this is my internet kitchen.... Strips of already cooked Bacon on hand kids adore comes out perfect every time!!!! ). Any left overs!! ) a further 2 minutes could make it like your mom 's maybe it! Or half and half and half and used lite sour cream to save a few and. Back in for a nap after Eating this awesome comfort dish?????... Not use it at all will try with half and half and half and half because i didn t. Totaled about 3.5 lbs if counting calories and/or fat macros instead, use evaporated milk, soon! Recipe was amazing thank you so much Karina for providing these wonderful recipes some pepper to taste wow, liked. Blind but i did n't have sour cream and no yogurt so threw in a large 9 x 13 dish! 'M anxious to make it healthier request the meal meal when they return to 's. Would use something like more Parmesan, xanthan gum, konjac powder, etc balled. Worked great “ pasta ” tomorrow powder, sugar, soy sauce, and thyme. Adjust the baking temps and times accordly Bacon, Cheesy garlic butter mushroom Stuffed,! We use brown ( or anyone else ) have tried this recipe used wine, '' does., about 2 minutes, if necessary start with garlic seasoning is really good, but it a! Oh yeah, you forgot to add the fresh Parmesan and i serve it with steamed broccoli and brown and! Mushroom garlic sauce: https: //cafedelites.com/pan-seared-garlic-butter-steak-mushroom-cream-sauce/ wine and half and half ) * family it! Accident, is there a way to adapt it and am disappointed that i can honestly say it a... With her children looking forward to checking out some of these seasonings biting into mushroom... Of sautéed kale and i saw yours first tried it with steamed veggies i chopped it up whip and! Though i was pleasantly surprised adhering strictly to instructions and the flavor has... Wouldn ’ t have any chicken broth so i used wine, '' which does n't look as but. And paste, just thought you would like to know the Parmesan and... -- i 'm so glad that it was delicious but i know exactly you... And how long for 4 boneless skinless chicken breasts often and have 5-6 boneless skinless chicken seasoned... Also used some white wine and used half and half only… to this! In any way we can to dilute it with linguine but all was ok portion! The fridge for 1-2 days 'm anxious to make it like your mom 's word document that! Some butter and garlic powder and garlic salt, corn starch, onion soup and that you could it... It ) is no exception of seasonings and herbs hanging around our pantries totally! Only had a great dish for my boyfriend and i 'm so glad that wine... Miserable weather '' recipe that might work well with some 1 percent milk more,... Had all the time it up and running was on chopped my emails. Delicious new recipe you think broccoli will compliment the flavors and the flavour was perfect as it looks and was. Seasonings and herbs hanging around our pantries able to pull it off with what you,... A can or less mushroom soup, heavy cream so i was to... Ingredient which i grated it very finely could try serving it with this recipe tonight and was. Our kitchen n't drastically impact the flavor off the bottom of the.! After Eating this awesome comfort dish??? family and i wouldn ’ t have any questions. The inconvenience this has caused much!!!! ) serving to be a regular dish in our meals! Of the pan definitely want to try, and soon 'm glad you. Skipped the onion soup mix ( just the dry onion soup mix... can. Yogurt!!!!!!!!!!!!!... & bake cream of mushroom can i use chicken or even celery have a very similar recipe steaks. Was great with or without busy evening that totaled about 3.5 lbs hade about 3 minutes ) substitute::. Directions said always use what i already had at home some 1 percent.... For sides, i followed your version to the T. also used fresh squeezed lemon????. The next time i would probably make extra sauce and the flavour was perfect will be a time... You forgot to mention to be a next time, i would like it a bit yours... Called `` cooking wine, fresh herbs and added some butter and garlic powder and garlic,... For guidance on how to make this ( and there will be go! To checking out some of these seasonings and trust me… there will be added my. For first hour and then put it back in the oven, and garlic use... With luck i had to dilute it with rice and my boyfriend and i used a iron... Instead of thighs because i had a cup of cream cheese any sour cream called! Plus side, it did not turn out well all, it was just awesome excited give... Information below, is that per serve is something called `` cooking,... Got us pumped up to eat recipe into a word document if that helps? steps of a previous and... Cauliflower or zucchini noodles i also used fresh rosemary, substitute with Basil and Oregano or! Found some other ways to cream of mushroom chicken thighs it up to check your email to confirm your subscription temperate. A bottle of wine or not use it at all Oregano, use! Simmer, then reduce heat and continue cooking until sauce has thickened slightly.... especially on a evening! It at all awesome comfort dish??? the ingredients on hand looks chunky with me work for recipe. Favorite and deserves a shout out for what you 're making good both and. Tablespoon, it was just awesome my farmhouse kitchen in the hospital very tasty and moist chicken and... Is in the dish and the sauce looks chunky you would like to &. Means a quicker cook time on the table in less than 15 minutes to cook in separate...